New York (CNN)Once part of Manhattan’s social elite, a 30-year-antique Princeton graduate lived off his dad and mom, prosecutors say, spending his time browsing inside the Hamptons — until he killed his father over a reduce to his weekly allowance.
“It wasn’t until the dad started cutting off his cash that the defendant decided to kill him,” said Craig Ortner, an assistant district attorney with the Manhattan district legal professional’s workplace. “Literally hours earlier than he became killed, (his father) further cut his allowance to $300.”
Thomas Gilbert Jr., now 34, has declined to seem in man or woman for tons of his 5-week trial on charges which include homicide and weapons possession, however, he turned into the present for final arguments Wednesday, wearing a white button-down blouse and slacks, his gaze diminished.
Tommy, as he’s acknowledged to own family and buddies, is being held at the Rikers Island prison. Defense legal professional Arnold Levine says his purchaser isn’t always guilty with the aid of purpose of insanity and has refused to cooperate with his own lawyers.
His father, Thomas Gilbert Sr., was a founding dealing with an associate at Wainscott Capital, a rewarding hedge fund, prosecutors say.
Thomas Jr. Is a former Princeton football participant who graduated with a degree in economics. At the time of the taking pictures in January 2015, he was 30 and unemployed, receiving up to $1,000 a week from his mother and father.
Prosecutors and his very own lawyers do no longer dispute that he killed his father. Jurors will instead be tasked with finding out whether or not he is responsible for the fees — which also include counts for forgery — or no longer guilty via reason of madness. The homicide price contains a sentence of 25 years to lifestyles in prison.
‘Nobody wanted to assume it’
Gilbert spent his younger years at luxurious, noticeably selective East Coast private schools. His lawyer confirmed jurors snippets of his grades, SAT rankings and trainer critiques from excessive school.
“Tommy’s paintings — certainly his complete way — this time period has been the success tale I still thrill to witness,” wrote a teacher from his sophomore year.
But, Levine stated, Gilbert “deteriorated” across the time he commenced to attend Princeton.
“Nobody desired to look at him — that heritage, the ones appear, that training — and say he can be mentally ill,” Levine said. “Nobody desired to suppose it.”
His former therapist, Susan Evans, testified that she saw him for several years earlier than the capturing and that his preoccupation with paranoid thoughts became “interfering” together with his capacity to function.
“I don’t accept as true with he become working or ever worked all through that point,” Evans stated. “Earlier on, he becomes preparing inventory precise reports for a pal of his father’s. I suppose that he failed to hold that up.”
Evans recommended that Gilbert be screened for paranoid schizophrenia inside the months before the incident. Other former medical doctors testified that they prescribed him antipsychotic medication. Evans testified that he did no longer take his prescribed medicines for a maximum of the time she saw him.
Emails between Gilbert and his parents that had been shown in court docket depict a tumultuous dating. He time and again requested for cash, occasionally “for a charity component,” every now and then forwarding past-due bills from an extraordinary athletic and social club for heaps of dollars to his mother.
In October 2013, Gilbert emailed his father, asking him for space.
“The more you recognize my area, the greater I will respect you!” he wrote.
Weeks later, though, he emailed his mom several times asking for hundreds of bucks for storage, clothes and inventory services. He bought a gun inside the summer season of 2014, prosecutors say, and a few months later, his father started out discussing reducing his allowance.
A voicemail from Thomas Sr. Describes his desire to foster financial independence in his son, but the defense stated that Thomas Sr. Had thousands of bucks in credit score card debt.
In October 2014, prosecutors say, Gilbert’s laptop confirmed searches for websites that mentioned forging exams and presented blank check templates. Some of the costs he faces stem from credit score card forging gadgets determined at his domestic at the time of his arrest, prosecutors say.
In November 2014, prosecutors say, his laptop showed searches for websites like “Hire-a-Killer.Com” and “Find-a-Hitman.Com.”
Shortly after, Thomas Sr. Emailed his son, telling him his weekly allowance might be decreased from $800 to $600. On the day of his demise, he modified his regular deposit into his son’s account to $three hundred, bank information showed.
On January four, 2015, Shelley Gilbert determined her husband on the bedroom ground of their Manhattan rental with a gunshot wound to his head and a gun on his chest.
Minutes earlier than, Gilbert had are available and cleared his mom out of the apartment, asking her to get him a sandwich and a drink, she testified.
Levine has argued that his consumer turned into clinically insane for the duration of the capturing. But prosecutors and their health workers say he knew that what he changed into doing was wrong.
Prosecutors factor to surveillance pictures that suggest Gilbert, wearing a hoodie and carrying a gym bag, getting into his family’s posh condo constructing just after 3 p.M. And leaving much less than 15 minutes later.
Forensic psychiatrist Jason Hershberger, who did no longer personally have a look at Gilbert because he declined to be visible, testified that he has read Gilbert’s scientific information and records associated with the incident.
“I realize that he shot his father,” Hershberger testified. “I recognize that his father becomes located as though he had shot himself. The gun becomes in his hand as though he had devoted suicide. Then Thomas left the scene. He became off the location monitor [on his phone]. He was in his domestic within the dark when the police got here to knock on his door. He pretended he wasn’t there.”
Hershberger testified that he does now not trust there is evidence to aid Gilbert’s plea of not guilty by using the motive of madness.
“In my opinion, every person who attempts to conceal his behavior around a criminal offense do so because they’re privy to what they may be doing is inaccurate,” he testified.
In New York, a defendant has to show their incapability to distinguish proper from incorrect on the way to win a madness plea defense.
Gilbert turned into deemed in shape to stand trial after undergoing four mental reviews, one in all which turned into inconclusive.
His attorney argues that Gilbert’s family attempted to get help for his mental contamination for over a decade.
“He faked being properly for 12 years,” Levine stated. “He failed to faux being sick; he faked being nicely.”
Shelley Gilbert’s 911 name changed into played in Manhattan Supreme Court.
When an emergency dispatcher requested who shot her husband, she responded, “My son, who’s nuts, but I didn’t recognize he changed into this nuts.”
CORRECTION: An earlier model of this text had the incorrect first call for Thomas Gilbert Jr.’s attorney. He is Arnold Levine. A reference to credit score card debt has to have mentioned the father, not the son.